Situated in the heart of Hamilton, Ontario, Tony G’s Pizzeria has quickly carved a niche for itself among pizza aficionados. Located at 30 John St N, this gem delivers an authentic taste of New York-style pizza that transports your taste buds straight to the bustling streets of Brooklyn.
As soon as you step inside, you are greeted by the warm atmosphere and the comforting aroma of freshly baked pizza. Tony G’s Pizzeria prides itself on using high-quality, international ingredients to create exceptional pies. The menu boasts a variety of options, including the New York Pepperoni, Classic NY Cheese, and the indulgent OG HammerTown Deluxe. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic or something a bit more adventurous like the Bomba or Hawaii Five0, each recipe reflects the care and passion that Tony G himself pours into his craft.
Reviews from patrons echo a consistent sentiment of satisfaction. One customer, Jon Yip Chuck, highlights the “thin crust, fresh toppings, and loads of cheese," emphasizing that the wait for a table—even on a busy Saturday evening—is well worth it. The dedication to quality shines through every slice, making it easy to understand why many consider this pizzeria a staple in Hamilton.
What sets Tony G’s apart isn’t just the pizza; it’s also the outstanding hospitality. Customers rave about the friendly service, noting instances where Tony G himself turns a mishap into a pleasant experience. Dave Elfassy recounts how Tony generously provided a replacement pizza after an accidental drop, showcasing his dedicated approach to customer care. This personal touch makes diners feel like family, not just customers.
The dough is always made fresh, cooked to perfection, and paired with savory sauce that some describe as “to die for.” Christina O mentioned her delight with the Bronx pizza, calling it “one of the best” she’s ever had, while Yohance Johnson praised the flavorful cheese and sauce crafted with love. For those who enjoy a sidekick with their pizza, many recommend trying the garlic dip, perfectly complementing the crispy crust.
In a vibrant city, Tony G’s Pizzeria stands out as a beacon for pizza lovers. With a menu filled with flavorful options and a welcoming spirit, this establishment invites you to experience pizza the way it was meant to be—rich in flavor and brimming with love. Don’t miss the opportunity to savor a slice of heaven at Tony G’s. Trust us, you’ll want to keep coming back for more!
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
919 Upper Paradise Rd #4, Hamilton, ON L9B 2M9, Canada
28425 SE Hwy 212, Boring, OR 97009, United States
Rosini 2a, 52446, Nova Vas, Croatia
Gutenbergstraße 1, 23611 Bad Schwartau, Germany
208 Tambon Bang Khut, Sankhaburi District, Chai Nat 17140, Thailand
193A-G and 193A-1, Dataran Cheras 9, Dataran Perniagaan Cheras 9, Balakong, 43200 Cheras, Selangor, Malaysia
Discover new menus and trending dishes on Menustic.
Menustic helps you discover menus from restaurants, cafés, and bars around the world. Explore destinations, compare dishes and prices, and decide where to eat or drink — Fantastic Menus, One Click Away.
© 2026 Menustic. Built to help people discover menus and decide what to eat and drink.
Jon Yip Chuck
15/10/2025
Excellent NY style Pizza! Thin crust, fresh toppings, and loads of cheese! If that quintessential NY slice is what you're craving Tony G's will not disappoint! Reasonably priced and friendly service. We ordered 30 minutes ahead on a Saturday evening and still had to wait close to another 30 when we got there, so keep in mind they can get very busy. That said it was worth the wait and will definitely be ordering many more times. Highly recommend!
Dave Elfassy
24/09/2025
Tony G’s Pizzeria is the real deal — authentic Brooklyn pizza at its finest. The cheese and sauce are made in-house with international ingredients, and you can taste the love in every bite. The flavors were spot on, rich, and truly authentic. We even got to meet the man, the myth, the legend himself — Tony G. He was everything people say and more: super sweet, down-to-earth, and made us feel right at home. When I accidentally dropped half my pizza, he didn’t think twice — he brought out a fresh medium pie for me. That’s just who he is. Salt-of-the-earth kind of guy who takes pride in what he does and how he treats people. Between the amazing food and the even better hospitality, this was an all-around great experience. We’ll definitely be back for more of Tony G’s incredible pies!
Christina O
25/08/2025
Now this is what I call a pizza, it’s so well cooked and literally the perfect pizza and one of then best I’ve ever had. I’m a basic person but went with the Bronx one and it was so good and the sizes are so big so the large was big enough and my husband who isn’t really a pizza guy really liked it. Great customer service and will definitely be back!!
Yohance Johnson
29/07/2025
Ordered a large cheese pizza. The pizza sauce and cheese is to die for. Absolutely delicious pizza made with love, fresh. Exceptionally great service from Angelo, very nice guy. Thanks for the great food, will definitely be back.
Lucy T
26/07/2025
Tried this pizza spot on Saturday night and woww…that ny pepperoni slice was TASTY. The dough was fresh and cooked to perfection. Exactly how I like it. The garlic dip? Yummy. Service was amazing too. I was greeted and welcomed right away by the gentlemen working there. Honestly 10/10 experience. I’ll definitely be back!
Kiki A.
13/07/2025
Absolutely incredible pizza—easily the best we’ve had in a long time. We ordered the New York Pepperoni, It’s a Bronx Thing, and the Classic Cheese, and every single slice was perfection. The thin crust had the ideal crispiness, the sauce was rich and balanced, and the mozzarella—made in-house—was so fresh and flavourful it truly took things to the next level. It honestly reminded us of the pizza we had in NYC. You can tell there's real attention to detail in every element, from the dough to the toppings. This place is a total gem. If you're craving authentic Brooklyn-style pizza and wings done right, Tony G's should be your next stop. We can’t wait to come back.
Bruce Wayne
03/07/2025
Tony G’s is hands down my favourite pizza joint!! I swear I died and went straight to pizza heaven! The pizza and wings are the real deal: authentic New York style, and the best part is you don’t even need to cross the border to get that true American flavor. They make everything in-house (yes, even the cheese!), and it really shows in the taste. On top of that, the staff are super friendly and welcoming, which makes the whole experience even better. I tell everyone I know how amazing this place is, and if you haven’t tried it yet… you NEED TO!!!! Support local and treat yourself — Tony G’s will not disappoint.
Michael Furtado
25/06/2025
I was looking for good pizza, and that’s exactly what I got at Tony G’s Pizzeria in Hamilton. From the very first bite, it was clear that the ingredients were top-quality and incredibly fresh — you can taste the difference in every slice. The crust was perfectly baked, the sauce rich and flavorful, and the toppings generous without being overdone. What stood out just as much as the food was the passion and craftsmanship of the staff. You can tell they truly care about what they’re making, putting pride into every pizza that comes out of the oven. There’s a sense of class and professionalism here that makes the whole experience even better. Tony G’s isn’t just serving pizza — they’re serving a piece of their dedication to great food, and it shows. Highly recommend to anyone craving a real, quality pizza experience.